Awards & Testimonials
Cape Cod Magazine
March 2013 “Best Brunch on Cape Cod!”
2016 – Best Sunday Brunch
2012 – Best Sunday Brunch
2012 – Best Waitstaff
2012 – Best Place for Intimate Wedding
2011 – Best Sunday Brunch
Cape Cod Life Magazine – Best of Cape Cod
2016- – Romantic Restaurant, Gold
2016 – Best Wine List, Silver
2015 – Romantic Restaurant, Gold
2014 – Romantic Restaurant, Gold
2013 – Best Brunch, Gold
2013 – Best Wine List, Gold
2011 – Best Fine Dining, Silver
2010 – Best Fine Dining, Silver
2010 – Romantic Restaurant, Editor’s Choice
2002-2015 – Award of Excellence
From Our Customers
“Like a fine bottle of wine, this special restaurant gets even better with age!”
5 of 5 stars2 weeks agoReviewed by stjaquabay
We have been dining at the Old Yarmouth Inn at least a few times a month for approximately four years now and each visit has been even better than the last. The restaurant has an interesting history as well as a nice, comfortable atmosphere; both locals and tourists are greeted with warmth by the wonderful, caring owners and friendly, conscientious staff making everyone feel very welcome. We have enjoyed dinners with friends, scrumptious Sunday brunches, birthday parties and our many “date nights” at the OYI, all very positive experiences. As for the cuisine; delicious, fresh ingredients on a diverse menu updated seasonally. We often dine in the more casual tavern; our favorite appetizers are the Caesar Salad and the Lobster Bisque, both the best we have ever had! Whether you prefer the heartier bacon wrapped Filet Mignon or lighter seafood fare, the OYI will take your preferences to their excellent chef. Last night my husband had the scallops on a mixed medley vegetable risotto. I had the small Caesar Salad with grilled scallops on the side. We both shared a delicious Lemoncello Cake and an Espresso Martini for dessert, (did I mention the bartenders are great too?) An incredible finish to an exceptional meal!
“Pre-Show Group Dinner”
5 of 5 starsReviewed 1 week ago
A group of 8 decided that the Old Yarmouth Inn’s mid-Cape location would be a great place to meet before a concert in Hyannis. We were seated at a large double round table that allowed for conversation. The cocktail list gave us a few ideas for some Summer refreshment and I chose a draft beer from Cape Cod Beer. We shared Calamari (fried with garlic and peppers) Rice Paper Shrimp, Oysters Rockefeller (the best ever) and a lump crab cocktail. Haddock, Scallops, Fried Clams, Lobster Roll, Sole Picatta, Steak Salads…all prepared as described, looked good when presented and everything that should have been hot was and nobody complained about a thing. Bonus…service was outstanding. Thanks for a great night!
Dear Sheila and Arpad,
Thank you for your postcard, recently, thanking our group, the Dennis/Yarmouth Newcomers, for choosing your restaurant for
our end of the year dinner.
You not only met our expectations you exceeded them. The food was delicious, the room was set perfectly and most of all the service was outstanding. The waiters and waitresses not only served very efficiently they were so friendly and charming that it enhanced our experience even more.
Everyone had a wonderful evening and we were so pleased that all of our planning and preparations for the dinner worked out so successfully.
Thank you for being so professional, dependable and a pleasure to work with.
We hope to come again in the future and have another fabulous event.
Thanks so much,
John and Joyce Leogrande
Just a quick note to thank you for the wonderful time my wife and I had at the Old Yarmouth Inn on this past Saturday evening. We were celebrating our 50th Anniversary and wanted it to be a special evening. Many kudos to Sheila (the miracle worker), as she found a table for us as we did not have a reservation. Also, your hostess was so nice to us, bringing us a complimentary glass of champagne to help us celebrate! The food was excellent as was the service provided by Stacy our server. Thanks again, for making us feel special on this most important day!
Peter and Dianne Dahlborg
Arpad & Sheila, I wanted to take the time to let you know that I enjoyed yet another wonderful dinner at The Old Yarmouth Inn. Everything from the seating to dessert was a most enjoyable experience. The food was simply delicious. The service was exceptional. Since I recently moved to Yarmouth Port, I look forward to frequenting your establishment with friends and family in the days to come. Again, many thanks for establishing fine/friendly dining along route 6A.
Arped & Sheila, I can’t thank you enough for taking such good care of us last night for Chuck’s send off. As always we were treated like royalty. You both truly know what customer services is all about. We are so blessed to have Old Yarmouth Inn as our “special” place.